账号:
自动登录
密码:

浏览:162   回复:0

建筑的衔接和空间的配置——论文翻译3 [复制链接]

  • shishiran-zjut
  • 参与勋章

    研究勋章

    互助勋章

楼主  发表于 2021-12-21 12:26  

Through examining theoretical and practical challenges and refining links between modes of translations and theoretical positioning, it will be suggested that rather than insisting on particular models as ‘better’ or ‘worse’, questions of which type of model and the definitions and decisions in its making works better must be distinctly tied to research query and situation. This, it will be argued, necessitates theory that makes explicit not only modelling decisions in practice but their relation to theoretical positions and consequences, and relations of theoretical ‘ideals’ to limitations and possibilities intrinsic to models and modelling practices. This must be done critically and with care, as it is important to not confuse ‘highest correlation’ with ‘best theory’ prematurely, as that would lead towards the simple case that, as we know, a model that is made directly after observed socio-spatial practice will best correlate to this socio-spatial practice but essentially be a tautological rather than an 

analytic model.

通过研究理论实践上挑战,以及完善翻译模式理论定位之间的联系我们建议与其坚持特定的模式是 "更好 "或 "更坏"不如哪种类型的模式以及制定的定义和决定更好地与研究疑问和情况明确联系起来我们将论证就需要理论不仅明确实践中的建模决定,而且明确它们理论立场后果关系以及理论 "理想 "模型和建模实践固有的限制可能性的关系必须谨慎进行因为重要的是不要过早地将 "最高相关性 " "最佳理论 "混为一谈因为将导致一个简单的情况,即我们所知一个观察到的社会空间实践之后直接制作的模型这个社会空间实践相关,但本质是一个同义词不是一个分析模型。

It must also be acknowledged that the argument comes from a theoretical position as well as a position on the purpose of modelling is (e.g. Downes, 2011; McCarty, 2008; Marshall et al., 2018). This position is one from architecture, which in some respects deviates from one of, for instance, environmental psychology or geography. A differentiation I believe to be best clarified through the coming discussion. And while I acknowledge that the fields are interlinked, the difference can be crucial as it brings the particular state of architecture as having been made into play.

 

必须承认论点来自理论立场以及对建模目的立场例如Downes2011McCarty2008Marshall等人2018这个立场来自建筑学的立场它在某些方面偏离环境心理学地理学立场相信,通过接下来的讨论,这种区别最好的澄清虽然承认这些领域相互联系的,但这种区别可能至关重要的因为它使建筑学的特殊状态得到了发挥

Finally, the type of argument to come necessitates drawing out and extrapolating tendencies to highlight differences and challenges. My intentions in simplifying is thus not to neglect all the important work performed, but to distill what questions are at stake. It is also not the intent to simply criticize the field for developing largely through learning in and from practice—I will argue the contrary. It is, however, critique in the sense that it intends to raise questions of theoretical and methodological positions and the links made between analytic models and empirical findings.

 

最后接下来的论证类型需要引出和推断出各种倾向,以突出差异挑战  因此,我的简化意图并不是忽视所有已完成的重要工作,而是提炼出哪些问题是关键的意图不是简单地批评这个领域发展主要是通过在实践中学习和实践中学习--我将争论相反然而在这个意义上,它是批判打算提出理论方法论的立场以及分析模型经验发现之间的联系问题


网站指南